OK, another First Lady shows up as a cousin — 7th, 4 times removed.   The lineage presented agrees with my documentation all the way back to my 9th great grandmother, Elizabeth Cleverly (1623-1681), one generation from our MRCA, Thomas Talmadge (1595-1653).  I have a problem with attributing Talmadge as the father of Cleverly (whose married name was Hotchkiss).  Unless Elizabeth was married prior to her marriage to my 9th great grandfather, it does not explain the name change.   TO DO item to research!